Response to ASX Visual Estimate Query Letter
Released
Released
Announcement PDF
29 January 2024
Raj Logarajah
Senior Adviser, Listings Compliance
ASX Limited
Level 40, Central Park
152-158 St Georges Terrace
Perth WA 6000
By email: raj.logarajah@asx.com.au and ListingsCompliancePerth@asx.com.au
Dear Raj
Culpeo Minerals Limited (ASX: CPO) – Visual Estimate of Mineralisation - Query
Culpeo Minerals Limited (“CPO” or “Company”) refers to your letter dated 23 January 2024 entitled
“Culpeo Minerals Limited (‘CPO’): Visual Estimate of Mineralisation - Query” (“Letter”) in which you
requested certain information.
The Company’s responses to your queries are detailed below. Capitalised terms used in the response
have the same meaning as given in the Letter unless otherwise required:
1.
Please provide a detailed explanation regarding the processes and methodologies followed
to achieve the Visual Estimate. Please include details regarding whether the Competent
Person considered these processes and methodologies sufficient to ensure the Visual
Results were representative of the corresponding samples.
The onsite geologist collated detailed drill core logging information of the sample area and
high-resolution photographs of the drill core. These were carefully analysed by the Competent
Person, who also visually inspected the drill core photographs and discussed the results of the
logging with the onsite geologist. Based on the detailed logging information and review of
the drill core photographs, the Competent Person compiled a table of visual estimates of
copper minerals present, which indicated that the Visual Results were representative of the
corresponding sampled drill core intervals. Accordingly, the Competent Person considered
these processes and methodologies sufficient to ensure the Visual Results were
representative of the corresponding sampled drill core intervals. The table of visual estimates
was included as ‘Table 1 – Copper Intervals – Visual Estimates – Drillhole CMEQD002’ in
Announcement 1.
2.
Please confirm who drafted/prepared the Visual Estimate for release on MAP.
CPO confirms that Maxwell Tuesley (MAusIMM – No 111470) drafted/prepared the Visual
Estimate for release on MAP.
3.
Commenting specifically on the significant difference between the Visual Estimate (6%
Copper) and Assay Results (0.8% Copper), could you please explain:
3.1
how CPO’s directors were satisfied there was a reasonable basis upon which to
release the Visual Estimate on MAP; and
CPO notes that the 6% Visual Estimate of Copper Mineral detailed in Announcement
1 referred to copper mineral occurrence in the drill core and was not a reference to
copper grade. Table 1 detailed that the copper mineral, consisting of both
chalcopyrite and bornite, was detected in the core logging and upon visual inspection
of the core photographs.
CPO further notes that the Assay Results referred to in Announcement 2, referred to
an 0.8% copper grade, which is dissimilar from the chalcopyrite and bornite copper
mineral occurrence referred to in Announcement 1.
The visual estimates were made of copper mineral occurrence in the drill core, and
when comparing the mineral intercept from the assay results to that made in the
visual estimate, the width of mineralisation is very accurate. The estimate of copper
mineral occurrence was based on what the Competent Person identified in the core
and matched the assay results for the minerals that were identified.
In view of the above, and upon detailed review and discussion of the visual estimate
process with the Competent Person as part of its internal review processes, CPO’s
directors were satisfied there was a reasonable basis upon which to release the Visual
Estimate on MAP.
3.2
whether CPO and the Competent Person consider the Visual Estimate to be in
compliance with the:
3.2.1
ASX Listing Rules (including Listing Rule 3.1 and Chapter 5 of the Listing
Rules);
Yes, CPO and the Competent Person consider the Visual Estimate to be in
compliance with the ASX Listing Rules. As required by Listing Rule 3.1, it is
accurate, complete and not misleading. The announcement makes it clear
that it is based solely on a visual inspection of the core sample and that the
sample is yet to be assayed and analysed and contains sufficient detail and
material information for investors or their professional advisers to
understand the ramifications of the Visual Estimate and to assess its impact
on CPO’s share price.
CPO and the Competent Person consider the Visual Estimate to comply with
Chapter 5 of the Listing Rules as it:
1. includes as an appendix to the announcement, a separate report
providing all information that is material to understanding the Visual
Estimate in relation to each of the criteria in section 1 (sampling
techniques and data) and section 2 (reporting of exploration results) of
Table 1 in Appendix 5A (JORC Code) as required by Listing Rule 5.7.1 (refer
to sections 1 and 2 of Appendix A to the announcement);
2. includes a separate table setting out the information required pursuant
to Listing Rule 5.7.2 with respect to drill holes (refer to the table included
in Appendix B to the announcement); and
3. includes a competent person’s statement that complies with Listing Rule
5.22 (refer to the statement on page 8 of the announcement).
3.2.2
ASX Compliance Update; and
Yes, CPO and the Competent Person consider the announcement of the Visual
Estimate to be in compliance with the ASX Compliance Update due to the
style of mineralisation and what was apparent from the visual inspection.
CPO considers that the announcement containing the Visual Estimate
complies with ASX’s Compliance Update as it contains the following
information (which is consistent with the Best Practice note published by the
Australian Institute of Geoscientists (AIG) and ASX Guidance Note 8- Example
D):
1. it describes the nature of mineral occurrence (e.g. massive, disseminated,
in veins, forming veins or bands concordant or discordant with bedding or a
penetrative foliation observable in the host rock);
2. it identifies the minerals observed;
3. it estimates the abundances of any minerals observed (in the form of a
table with an estimate of the abundances at each interval of the applicable
hole or sample); and
4. it states the anticipated timing for the release of assay results in respect of
the visual estimates (being, mid-January 2024).
It also contains the proximate cautionary statement to any reported visual
estimates that is suggested in the Compliance Update.
3.2.3
the JORC Code (including clause 4 of the JORC code),
Yes, CPO and the Competent Person consider the Visual Estimate to be in
compliance with the requirements of Appendix 5A (JORC Code), including
clause 4 of the JORC Code. CPO and the Competent Person are cognitive of
the principles governing the operation and application of the JORC Code as
set out in clause 4 (transparency, materiality and competence) and consider
the Visual Estimate to be compliant with these principles as:
1. the information is sufficient, clear, unambiguous and not misleading;
2. the Visual Estimate contains all the relevant information which investors
and their professional advisers would reasonably require, and reasonably
expect to find in the report, for the purpose of making a reasoned and
balanced judgement regarding the Visual Estimate; and
3. the Visual Estimate was based on work that is the responsibility of
suitably qualified and experienced persons who are subject to an
enforceable professional code of ethics.
if the answer is yes, please explain the basis for this conclusion.
The basis for each conclusion is detailed above.
4.
On what date did CPO receive the assay results for the downhole interval of 30 metres to
55 metres for drill hole CMEQD002?
CPO received the final assay results for the downhole interval of 30 metres to 55 metres for
drill hole CMEQD002 on 12th January 2024.
5.
Please confirm that CPO is in compliance with the Listing Rules and, in particular, Listing
Rule 3.1.
CPO confirms that it is complying with Listing Rules and, in particular, Listing Rule 3.1.
6.
Please confirm that CPO’s responses to the above have been authorised and approved in
accordance with its published continuous disclosure policy or otherwise by its board or an
officer of CPO with delegated authority from the board to respond to ASX on disclosure
matters.
CPO confirms that the above responses have been authorised and approved by the Board of
Directors.
Yours sincerely
Sarah Wilson
Company Secretary
23 January 2024
Reference: 87137
Sarah Wilson
Company Secretary
Culpeo Minerals Limited
By email
Dear Sarah
Culpeo Minerals Limited (‘CPO’): Visual Estimate of Mineralisation - Query
ASX refers to the following:
A. CPO’s announcement entitled, “Broad Zones of Shallow, Visible Copper Intersected”, lodged on the ASX
Market Announcements Platform (‘MAP’) marked by CPO as ‘price sensitive’ and released at 9:20am AEDT
on 19 December 2023 (‘Announcement 1’) disclosing the following, among other things:
(i) in ‘Table 1 – Copper Intervals – Visual Estimates – Drillhole CMEQD002’ on page 4 of Announcement 1,
visual estimate of copper mineralisation of 6% in drill hole CMEQD002 within the downhole interval of
30 metres to 55 metres (‘Visual Estimate’):
Hole ID
From
(m)
To (m)
Interval
(m)
CMEQD002
30
55
25
Mineralisation
Style
Vein / Breccia
Copper Mineral
Visual Estimate
of Copper
Mineral
Chalcopyrite / Bornite
6%
(ii) under the header ‘Competent Persons’ Statements’ on page 8 of Announcement 1, a statement from
Mr. Maxwell Donald Tuesley (‘Competent Person’) in relation to exploration results included in
Announcement 1:
“The information in this announcement that relates to Exploration Results is based on information
compiled by Mr. Maxwell Donald Tuesley, BSc (Hons) Economic Geology, MAusIMM (No 111470). Mr.
Tuesley is a member of the Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy and is a shareholder and
Director of the Company. Mr. Tuesley has sufficient experience that is relevant to the style of
mineralisation and type of deposit under consideration and to the activity which he is undertaking to
qualify as a Competent Person as defined in the 2012 Edition of the Australasian Code for Reporting of
Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves. Mr. Tuesley consents to the inclusion in this
report of the matters based on this information in the form and context in which it appears.”
B. CPO’s announcement entitled, “Drilling Returns Significant Wide Copper Intersections”, lodged on MAP
marked by CPO as ‘price sensitive’ and released at 9:20am AEDT on 16 January 2024 (‘Announcement 2’)
disclosing the following, among other things:
(i) in ‘Table 2: Significant Assay Results from Drillhole CMEQD002’ on page 4 of the Announcement 2,
breakdown of the Assay results CPO in relation to drill hole CMEQD002 within the downhole interval of
30 metres to 55 metres (‘Assay Results’):
Hole ID
From
CMEQD002 30
ASX Limited [[Listings]]
#10682240v1
To
Width
Au g/t
Cu %
31
1
0.0025
0.32
Mo
ppm
10
Ag
g/t
CuEq %
0.05
0.33
ASX Customer Service Centre 131 279 | asx.com.au
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
CMEQD002
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53.1
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53.1
55
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1.1
1.9
0.0025
0.01
0.0025
0.0025
0.02
0.01
0.0025
0.01
0.01
0.009
0.006
0.013
0.025
0.012
0.008
0.009
0.006
0.005
0.014
0.007
0.066
0.035
0.01
0.20
0.85
0.27
0.18
0.95
1.65
0.41
0.89
0.80
0.66
0.19
0.57
1.72
0.68
0.60
0.88
0.17
0.37
0.19
0.22
2.09
2.02
1.61
10
10
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
10
10
5
5
5
0.05
0.05
1
0.05
0.05
0.05
1
0.05
1
1
1
0.05
1
1
1
0.05
1
1
1
2
2
2
1
0.21
0.86
0.28
0.18
0.96
1.66
0.42
0.89
0.81
0.67
0.20
0.57
1.75
0.69
0.61
0.89
0.18
0.38
0.20
0.24
2.14
2.05
1.62
(ii) in the body of Announcement 2 on page 2:
“From a downhole depth of 29m until 55m, a wider zone of sulphide mineralisation (Figure 2 and 3) was
intersected returning 26m and grading 0.81% CuEq. This wider intersection also returned a high grade
zone of 4m of 1.87% CuEq from 51 to 55m including 1m of 2.16% CuEq from 51m.”
(iii) under the header ‘Competent Persons’ Statements’ on page 9 of Announcement 2, a statement from the
Competent Person in relation to exploration results included in Announcement 2:
“The information in this announcement that relates to Exploration Results is based on information
compiled by Mr. Maxwell Donald Tuesley, BSc (Hons) Economic Geology, MAusIMM (No 111470). Mr.
Tuesley is a member of the Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy and is a shareholder and
Director of the Company. Mr. Tuesley has sufficient experience that is relevant to the style of
mineralisation and type of deposit under consideration and to the activity which he is undertaking to
qualify as a Competent Person as defined in the 2012 Edition of the Australasian Code for Reporting of
Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves. Mr. Tuesley consents to the inclusion in this
report of the matters based on this information in the form and context in which it appears.”
C. The change in CPO’s share price from a closing price of $0.10 on 12 January 2024 to a closing price of $0.047
on 16 January 2024 following release of the assay results contained in Announcement 2.
D. ASX Guidance Note 8 (section 4.15) which states:
2/5
ASX Customer Service Centre 131 279 | asx.com.au
#10682240v1
(i) ‘Wherever possible, an announcement under Listing Rule 3.1 should contain sufficient detail for investors
or their professional advisers to understand its ramifications and to assess its impact on the price or
value of the entity’s securities.’
(ii) ‘An announcement under Listing Rule 3.1 must be accurate, complete and not misleading. A listed entity
cannot satisfy its obligation to disclose market sensitive information under Listing Rule 3.1 by disclosing
information that is materially inaccurate, incomplete or misleading.
E. ASX Guidance Note 8- Example D, which states in relation to announcements containing visual estimates of
mineralisation:
“Whether disclosure is required at this stage would depend on the circumstances. In many cases, information
derived solely from a visual inspection of a core sample and before it has been assayed and analysed, would
be a matter of supposition and insufficiently definite to warrant disclosure. In those circumstances, disclosure
of the drilling results would not normally be expected until the drill core had been assayed and analysed.
There may be cases, however, depending on the style of mineralisation and what is apparent from the visual
inspection, where an announcement would be appropriate at this stage. In those cases, the announcement
should make it clear that it is based solely on a visual inspection of the core sample and that the sample is
yet to be assayed and analysed. It would generally be inappropriate to make any comments about the grade
or quality of the mineralisation in the announcement in the absence of an assay.
Regardless of whether the announcement is made on the basis of an assay and analysis or a visual inspection
of the core sample, the announcement must comply with the requirements in Chapter 5 and Appendix 5A of
the Listing Rules for reporting exploration results.”
F.
Listed at ASX Compliance Update no. 04/23 (‘ASX Compliance Update’), which states:
“ASX does not encourage the reporting of estimates of mineralisation based only on visual observations. ASX’s
existing guidance states that it would generally be inappropriate for an entity to comment about the grade
or quality of mineralisation in the absence of an assay. In many cases, information derived solely from a visual
inspection of a core sample before it has been assayed and analysed could give a misleading impression of
the extent of mineralisation.” Clause 4 of the JORC Code, which states:
“Transparency requires that the reader of a Public Report is provided with sufficient information, the
presentation of which is clear and unambiguous, to understand the report and not be misled by this
information or by omission of material information that is known to the Competent Person.”
Request for information
Having regard to the above, ASX asks CPO to respond separately to each of the following questions and requests
for information:
1. Please provide a detailed explanation regarding the processes and methodologies followed to achieve the
Visual Estimate. Please include details regarding whether the Competent Person considered these processes
and methodologies sufficient to ensure the Visual Results were representative of the corresponding samples.
2. Please confirm who drafted/prepared the Visual Estimate for release on MAP.
3. Commenting specifically on the significant difference between the Visual Estimate (6% Copper) and Assay
Results (0.8% Copper), could you please explain:
3.1
how CPO’s directors were satisfied there was a reasonable basis upon which to release the Visual
Estimate on MAP; and
3.2
whether CPO and the Competent Person consider the Visual Estimate to be in compliance with the:
3/5
ASX Customer Service Centre 131 279 | asx.com.au
#10682240v1
3.2.1
ASX Listing Rules (including Listing Rule 3.1 and Chapter 5 of the Listing Rules);
3.2.2
ASX Compliance Update; and
3.2.3
the JORC Code (including clause 4 of the JORC code),
if the answer is yes, please explain the basis for this conclusion.
4. On what date did CPO receive the assay results for the downhole interval of 30 metres to 55 metres for drill
hole CMEQD002?
5. Please confirm that CPO is in compliance with the Listing Rules and, in particular, Listing Rule 3.1.
6. Please confirm that CPO’s responses to the above have been authorised an approved in accordance with its
published continuous disclosure policy or otherwise by its board or an officer of CPO with delegated authority
from the board to respond to ASX on disclosure matters.
When and where to send your response
This request is made under Listing Rule 18.7. Your response is required as soon as reasonably possible and, in
any event, by no later than 2:30 PM AWST Wednesday, 31 January 2024. You should note that if the information
requested by this letter is information required to be given to ASX under Listing Rule 3.1 and it does not fall
within the exceptions mentioned in Listing Rule 3.1A, CPO’s obligation is to disclose the information
‘immediately’. This may require the information to be disclosed before the deadline set out in the previous
paragraph and may require CPO to request a trading halt immediately.
Your response should be sent to me by e-mail at ListingsCompliancePerth@asx.com.au. It should not be sent
directly to the ASX Market Announcements Office. This is to allow me to review your response to confirm that it
is in a form appropriate for release to the market, before it is published on the ASX Market Announcements
Platform.
Trading halt
If you are unable to respond to this letter by the time specified above, you should discuss with us whether it is
appropriate to request a trading halt in CPO’s securities under Listing Rule 17.1. If you wish a trading halt, you
must tell us:
the reasons for the trading halt;
how long you want the trading halt to last;
the event you expect to happen that will end the trading halt;
that you are not aware of any reason why the trading halt should not be granted; and
any other information necessary to inform the market about the trading halt, or that we ask for.
We require the request for a trading halt to be in writing. The trading halt cannot extend past the commencement
of normal trading on the second day after the day on which it is granted. You can find further information about
trading halts in Guidance Note 16 Trading Halts & Voluntary Suspensions.
Suspension
If you are unable to respond to this letter by the time specified above, ASX will likely suspend trading in CPO’s
securities under Listing Rule 17.3.
4/5
ASX Customer Service Centre 131 279 | asx.com.au
#10682240v1
Listing Rules 3.1 and 3.1A
In responding to this letter, you should have regard to CPO’s obligations under Listing Rules 3.1 and 3.1A and
also to Guidance Note 8 Continuous Disclosure: Listing Rules 3.1 – 3.1B. It should be noted that CPO’s obligation
to disclose information under Listing Rule 3.1 is not confined to, nor is it necessarily satisfied by, answering the
questions set out in this letter.
Release of correspondence between ASX and entity
ASX reserves the right to release all or any part of this letter, your reply and any other related correspondence
between us to the market under Listing Rule 18.7A.
Questions
If you have any questions in relation to the above, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Yours sincerely
Raj Logarajah
Senior Adviser, Listings Compliance
5/5
ASX Customer Service Centre 131 279 | asx.com.au
#10682240v1
Share your feedback
Discover